Member-only story

Thucydides and the human condition

Figs in Winter
6 min readNov 27, 2019
Thucydides

In the year 427 BCE, not long after the onset of the Peloponnesian War, Sparta took its time to send naval relief to the allied city of Mytilene, which had recently revolted against Sparta’s longtime rival, Athens. As a result, the city was captured by an Athenian contingent. This would have been just one more of a number of back-and-forth episodes between Sparta and Athens, which lasted from 431 to 404 BCE and which, even though it technically ended with a Spartan victory, weakened all of the Greek city-states, thereby opening the way for the Macedonian conquest of all Greece, which began in 338 BCE.

What sets aside the Mytilenean revolt is that Thucydides wrote about it in detail in his classic, The History of the Peloponnesian War (full text here). And what makes me write about it is one of the speeches connected to that episode and recorded by Thucydides. It contains some fascinating insight into the human condition, and reminds us that things have not changed that much, in certain respects, over the past two and a half millennia.

What happened after the Athenians entered Mytilene is that they captured the ringleaders of the revolt and brought them back to Athens for an hearing. The discussion was held in the open assembly, as Athens was a democratic polis. One party, led by Cleon, son of Cleaenetus, advocated for what we would today call genocide: kill all the men in Mytilene, and enslave all women and children.

Cleon is remarkably frank about Athenian imperialism. Here is an excerpt from Thucydides’ account of his speech:

“You should remember that your empire is a despotism exercised over unwilling subjects, who are always conspiring against you; they do not obey in return for any kindness which you do them to your own injury, but in so far as you are their masters; they have no love of you, but they are held down by force.” (III.37)

How refreshing. No paternalistic nonsense about taking care of other people for their own benefit, as so much modern imperialism attempts to do. Cleon reminds his fellow citizens of the naked truth: the Athenian…

--

--

Figs in Winter
Figs in Winter

Written by Figs in Winter

by Massimo Pigliucci, a scientist, philosopher, and Professor at the City College of New York. Exploring and practicing Stoicism & other philosophies of life.

No responses yet